A new study by three economists suggests that elementary- and middle-school teachers who help increase their students' standardized-test scores have a significant, positive and lasting impact on those students' lives in the long term. Their influence extends beyond academics, as good teachers also mean "lower teenage-pregnancy rates and greater college matriculation and adult earnings," writes the New York Times. The study tracked the lives of 2.5 million students over 20 years, "allowing for a deeper look at how much the quality of individual teachers matters over the long term."
Although the economists set out to challenge the use of value-added ratings, which according to the Times "measure the impact individual teachers have on student test scores," researchers ultimately found that "controlling for numerous factors, including students’ backgrounds...the value-added scores consistently identified
some teachers as better than others, even if individual teachers’
value-added scores varied from year to year." They concluded that "using value-added scores would lead to fewer mistakes, not more."
And the positive effect of teachers who increased student test scores was striking. The Times notes, "Replacing a poor teacher with an average one would raise a single
classroom’s lifetime earnings by about $266,000, the economists
estimate. Multiply that by a career’s worth of classrooms." The researchers surmise that the same results would be obtained by replacing an average teacher with an excellent teacher: "Given the difficulty of finding, training and retaining outstanding
teachers...the difference in long-term outcome between students
who have average teachers and those with poor-performing ones is as
significant as the difference between those who have excellent teachers
and those with average ones."
The positive effect of an excellent teacher on one individual student is less impressive than that teacher's potential impact on the entire class taken together, of course. "All else equal, a student with one excellent teacher for one year
between fourth and eighth grade would gain $4,600 in lifetime income,
compared to a student of similar demographics who has an average
teacher. The student with the excellent teacher would also be 0.5
percent more likely to attend college." Still, "students with top teachers are less likely to become pregnant as
teenagers, more likely to enroll in college, and more likely to earn
more money as adults."
The study will likely add fuel to the value-added score debate, as many people--and teachers' unions--"say that isolating the effect of a given teacher is harder than it seems, and might unfairly penalize some instructors." The researchers of this study are firmly on the other side: "The authors argue that school districts should use value-added measures
in evaluations, and...remove the lowest performers." One of the researchers, Harvard Professor John N. Friedman, was quoted in the Times as saying, “The message is to fire people sooner rather than later.”
Unknown
Related Posts:
About TeachingwithData.org
TeachingWithData.org is a partnership between the Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research (ICPSR) and the Social Science Data Analysis Network (SSDAN), both at the University of Michigan. The project is funded by NSF Award 0840642, George Alter (ICPSR), PI and William Frey (SSDAN), co-PI.
Translate
Search This Blog
Popular Posts
-
A study recently featured in the Journal of Comparative Economics examines income inequality in urban China. Capital income increased d...
-
If you’ve hit the point in the semester where your classes have fallen into routines and you’d like to spice things up a bit, this webinar i...
-
A recent post on the Economist’s Graphic Detail blog includes a global map of cigarette smokers in 2010, as reported by the American Cance...
-
According to the Washington Post, since 2009, the unemployment rate in the United States has dropped by 50% . The traditional...
-
The month of March signaled the beginning of National Women’s History Month, as well as the annual Oscar Awards ceremony, which was held on...
Your new study really authentic because I have also get some stats from affordable writing company and they provided me the same stats which you have stated above.
ReplyDelete